2015 Canadian Medical Marijuana Outlook: Foggy with Sunny Patches
- Tweed Marinuana Inc. (TSX.V:TWD)(OTCMKTS:TWMJF)
- Bedrocan Cannabis Corp. (TSX.V:BED) (OTCMKTS:BNRDF)
- Organigram Holdings Inc. (TSX.V:OGI) (OTCMKTS:OGRMF)
- T-Bird Pharma Inc (TSX.V:TPI)
- PharmaCan Capital Corp (TSX.V:MJN)
- Mettrum Health Corp. (CVE:MT)
- Aphria Inc. (CVE:APH
Companies Discussed in this Article
The Canadian Medical Marijuana experience for investors has for the most part been a tremendous letdown thus far. When Tweed Marijuana Inc. (TSX.V:TWD) lost 10 percent on its first day open of $3.32, and as of Friday last week accumulated a total YTD loss of 41 percent, the writing was on the wall.
Of course, that does not apply to insiders and early stage investors. Tweed founders paid as little as $0.15 a share, and their instant wealth came at the direct expense of retail investors.
But that is the game, and anybody who cries about it has no business investing in it.
Since Tweed’s underwhelming debut, there have been millions of dollars vaped by both licensed producers who are publicly traded, publicly traded mining companies who say they are on the cusp of a sex change, and even private co’s who are locked in liquidity limbo as their applications for production licenses flutter uselessly in the wind like war-ravaged flags. ‘Burn rate’ has taken on a whole new meaning in this context.
From the abysmal and bizarre rantings of CEN Biotech’s embarrassing and ludicrous claims that its going to produce “600,000 kilograms” of dried marijuana per year, to the quiet sophistication of Bedrocan Canada’s automated no-touch production systems for genetically identical strains of pharmaceutical grade marijuana, the range of experiences for investors mirrors the range of credibility in the industry.
A year into the publicly traded marijuana company experience, profit and capital gains remain elusive. So what’s the prognosis? Where is there a credible forecast on who’s going to win and who’s going to lose?
The Canadian Securities Regulators, in classic ‘slam-shut-the-barn-doors-after-the-horses-escaped’ form, issued a second warning against the medical marijuana industry as a whole.
As with any industry, there are always an evolving set of threats and opportunities that are exacerbated or ameliorated according to individual strengths and weaknesses.
Here then is an overview of those threats and opportunities, followed by a summary take on each of the publicly traded medical marijuana companies.
Industry-Wide Threats Specific to Canadian MMPR Companies
There are two significant threats to the entire MMPR-regulated roster of companies that could send the entire industry into a terminal downward spiral.
The Allard Case
Just before the official MMPR rules took effect on April 1st, 2014, a group of medical marijuana users who were licensed under the forerunner to MMPR, Medical Marijuana Access Regulations, challenged in the Supreme Court of British Columbia the constitutionality of being forced to source their weed from MMPR registered growers.
They were successful, and obtained Injunctive Relief from Judge Michael Manson who found that, among other conclusions,
“The Applicants who held, as of September 30, 2013, or were issued thereafter a valid Personal-use Production License pursuant to section 24 of the Marihuana Medical Access Regulations, or a Designated-person Production Licence pursuant to section 34 of the Marihuana Medical Access Regulations, are exempt from the repeal of the Marihuana Medical Access Regulations and any other operation of the Marihuana for Medical Purposes Regulations which is inconsistent with the operation of the Marihuana Medical Access Regulations, to the extent that the Designated-person Production License or Personal-use Production License held by the Applicant shall remain valid until such time as a decision in this case is rendered at trial and subject to the terms of paragraph 4 of this Order”
So they are allowed to continue to grow their own and source their own until the outcome of the supreme court appeal by Health Canada, now in its fourth week in Vancouver, British Columbia.
The implication, if the Supreme Court decides to permanently enshrine an individual’s right to grow their own marijuana in law, is that all Canadian medical users of marijuana might then have the right to produce their own pot over sourcing it from MMPR growers, thus undermining the entire investment thesis of the industry.
Growers who I’ve spoken with disagree, and uniformly opine that regardless of the outcome of the Allard challenge, MMPR will apply to all subsequent prescription holders of medical marijuana. That belief, however, is inconsistent with history, and smacks more of a belief in what they need to believe.
So that’s one major potential wrinkle in the blanket.
Vancouver Cops Not Enforcing Laws
Meanwhile, in Vancouver, city police have elected to ignore the law against marijuana sale and possession, which has given rise to at least 60 new ‘dispensaries’ that provide weed for as little as $4 a gram. While there is supposedly a requirement for a doctor’s prescription, those without can log onto Skype and receive one in under two minutes simply by claiming stress as a medical condition. Essentially, this is a wide open market for recreational marijuana.
This is tantamount to undermining the viability of licensed producers and of the entire MMPR regime. If these unregulated and thus lower cost vendors are allowed to proliferate, it will be very difficult for MMPR producers to garner market share.
In the United States, Washington State growers are already going out of business en masse thanks to a glut of supply, and the same is nervously anticipated in Colorado. The problem of course being that, at the end of the day, marijuana is about as tough to grow as canola, and will suffer commodity pricing as a result. Thus only the biggest, cheapest growers will survive.
Here’s the visual summary of the publicly traded MMPR producer’s performance to date. The order reflects the order in which the companies went public.
Tweed Marijuana Inc.
[four_fifth_last padding=”0 0 0 20px”]Listen to an interview with Tweed Marijuana CEO Bruce Linton:
Bedrocan Cannabis Corp
[four_fifth_last padding=”0 0 0 20px”]Listen to the interview with Bedrocan CEO Marc Wayne:
OrganiGram Holdings Inc
[four_fifth_last padding=”0 0 0 20px”]Listen to an interview with OrganiGram CEO Denis Arsenault:
T-Bird Pharma Inc.
|Last Trade:||0.495||Day’s Range||0.495 – 0.55|
|Trade Time:||Mar 17||52wk Range:||0.35 – 0.95|
|Prev Close:||0.53||Avg Vol (3m):||74,405|
|Bid:||0.495 x N/A||P/E (ttm):||N/A|
|Ask:||0.55 x N/A||EPS (ttm):||-0.04|
|1Y Target Est:||N/A||Div & Yield:||N/A (N/A)|
[four_fifth_last padding=”0 0 0 20px”]Listen to an interview with T-Bird Pharma CEO Robert Gagnon:
Mettrum Health Corp.
[four_fifth_last padding=”0 0 0 20px”]No Interview with Mettrum CEO Michael Haines despite multiple invitations:
PharmaCan Capital Corp
[four_fifth_last padding=”0 0 0 20px”]Listen to an interview with PharmaCan CEO Paul Rosen:
[four_fifth_last padding=”0 0 0 20px”]No Interview with Aphria CEO Vic Neufeld available despite repeated invitations.
Buy, Sell or Hold?
A lot of investors have rushed into the medical marijuana sector and lost their money. There is a new wave of publicly traded marijuana companies on the horizon, though these typically are not pure producers. MidasLetter ranks and quantifies all the producers publicly listed in Canada for subscribers.
Learn more at http://10.0.1.189:8888/midasletter_old/subscribe.